Validation of Chains of Imam Reza's ilal ol-ahkam(causes of rules) letter with an emphasis on reliability analysis of Mohammad Ibn Sanan

Document Type : Research Paper

Abstract

Imam reza's correspondence in response to questions of Mohammad ibn Sanan al-zaheri about the explaining the causes of ordinances and laws has several chains that have raised in Uyun akhbar al-reza and Man la yahzoroho al-faqih books. These chains in basic and pure Rejali attitudes, due to weak narrators, seem to be invalid and weak, in addition to the weakness of the chains, the possibility of forgery correspondence by Mohammad ibn Sanan is also been raised. In this study, the critical assessment of weaknesses of the correspondence chains been discussed and reliability of narrators and the validity of these chains has been proved. The possibility of forging correspondence by Mohammad bin Sanan is also been rejected through conform with many of correspondence concepts with the same words and with phrases close to words in other ahl al-bayt traditions as well as the quotation of the correspondence by traditionists aware of the conditions of Mohammad ibn Sanan. After proving the validity of correspondence in rational manner that is based on avoiding the detailed conversations or correspondence on important and effective issues like explanation for causes and philosophy of Islamic rulings with an unreliable person and who are reputed to lie, this detailed and important correspondence is considered the discoverer of Imam confidence to this narrator and he accepted as a reliable narrator to the Shiite companions.

Keywords

Main Subjects


  1. Ibn Dāwūd, Hasan ibn ʽAli Hillī (2004), Rijāl ibn Dāwūd, Tehran:  Enteshārāt Dāneshgāh Tehran.
  1. Ibn Shahr Āshūb, Muhammad ibn ʽAlī Māzandarānī (2000), Manāgib Āl Abī Ṭālib, Qom, Muʼassish Intishārāt ʽAllāmeh
  2. Jaʽfarī Langrūdī, Muhammad Jaʽfar (2011), Mabsūṭ Dar Tirmīnuluzhī Huqūq Tehran: Kitabkhaneh Ganj Dānish.
  3. Khomeini Sayyed Rūhullah Mūsavī (2006), Rasāʼil, Qom: Ismāʽīlīyān.
  4. Sadūq, Muhammad ibn ʽAlī ibn Bābiwayh Qomī (1983), Amālī, Tehran: Enteshārāt Kitābkhāneh Islāmī.
  1. Inb Ṭāwūs, Sayyid Raḍī al-Dīn ʽAlī ibn Mūsā (1993), Falāh al-Sāīl Wa Najāh al-Masāʽil Qom: Daftar Tablīghāt Islāmī.
  2. Ibn al-Ghazāirī, Ahmad ibn Hussein (2001), Rijal ibn al-Ghazāirī (kītāb al-Ḍuʽafā, Qom: Muʼassiseh Ismāʽīlīyān
  3. Bahr al-Ulūm, Sayyid Muhammad Mahdī, (1984), al-Fawāid al-Rrijālīyya, Tehran: Maktabah al-Ṣādiq
  4. Barqī, Ahmad ibn Muhammad ibn Khālid (2004), Rijāl al-Barqī(al-Ṭabaqāt) Tehran: Intishārāt Dāneshgāh Tehran
  1. Hurr ʽAmulī, Muhammad ibn Hasan(1988), Wasāʽīl al-Shīʽa, Qom: Muʼassisah Āl al-Bayt
  2. Khādem Pīr, ʽAlī, (2006) "Barrisī Tusīf Rijālī Muhammad ibn Sanān" Majalleh Hadīth Andīsheh, vol:2, pages 67-79
  1. Khuʼī, Sayyid Abulgāsim Mūsawī ((1992), Muʽjam al-Rijāl al-Hadīth. Qom: Markaz Āthār Shīʽa.
  2. Zurrārī, Abī Ghalib Ahmad ibn Sulaymān (1990) Rasāʼil, Qom: Markaz Tahqiqāt Va Pazhūheshhayeh Islāmī.
  3. Subhānī, Jaʽfar, (1993), Kullīyāt Fī ʽIlm Rijāl, Qom: Muʼassiseh al-Nashr al-Īslāmī.
  4. Shahīd ʼAwwal, Muhammad ibn Makkī ʽĀmilī (1998), Dhikrā al-Shīʽa, Qom: Āl al-Bayt.
  5. Shahīd ʼAwwal, Muhammad ibn Makkī ʽĀmilī (1993), Ghāyat al-Murād fī Sharh Nukat al-Īrshād, Qom: Daftar Tablīghāt Islāmī.
  6. Shahīd Thānī, Zayn al-Ddīn ʽAlī ʽĀmilī (2011), Sharh al-Bidāyah fī ʽIlm al-Dirāyah, Qom: Ḍīyāʽ Fīrūz Ābādī.
  1. Sadūq, Muhammad ibn ʽAlī ibn Bābiwayh Qomī (1977), al-Tuhīd, Qom: Enteshārāt Jāmiʽeh Mudarresīn.
  2. Sadūq, Muhammad ibn ʽAlī ibn Bābiwayh Qomī (1982), al-Khiḍāl, Qom: Enteshārāt Jāmiʽeh Mudarresīn.
  3. Sadūq, Muhammad ibn ʽAlī ibn Bābiwayh Qomī (n,d), ʽIlal al-Sharāʼiʽ, Qom: Īntishārāt Maktabah al-Dāwarī.
  4. Sadūq, Muhammad ibn ʽAlī ibn Bābiwayh Qomī (1957), ʽUyūn Akhbār al-Riḍā, Tehran: Enteshārāt Jahān.
  5. Sadūq, Muhammad ibn ʽAlī ibn Bābiwayh Qomī (1974), Kamāl al-dīn, Qom: Dār al-Kutub al-Islāmīyah.
  6. Sadūq, Muhammad ibn ʽAlī ibn Bābiwayh Qomī (1962), Maʽānī al-Akhbār, Qom: Enteshārāt Jāmiʽeh Mudarresīn.
  7. Sadūq, Muhammad ibn ʽAlī ibn Bābiwayh Qomī (1992), Man lā-Yahḍaruh al-Faqīh, Qom: Enteshārāt Jāmiʽeh Mudarresīn.
  8.  Ṭaherī Habīb Allah (2012) Va Muhammad Hakīm "ʼIʽtibār Sanjī Va Naqd Taḍʽīf Rijālī Muhammad ibn Sanān Va Taʼthīr Ān Bar Faqīh Imāmīyeh" Majalleh Pazhuheshhāye Feqhī, (8), vol: 1, pages: 133-160
  9. Ṭabrisī, Ahmad ibn ʽAlī (1982) al-Īhtijāj, Mashhad Muqaddas: Nashr Murteḍā.
  10. Ṭūsī, Abū Jaʽfar Muhammad ibn Hasan (1986) Tahdhīb al-Ahkām, Tehran: Dār al-Kutub Islāmīyah.
  11. Ṭūsī, Abū Jaʽfar Muhammad ibn Hasan (1986) al-Rijāl, Najaf: Enteshārāt Hiydarīyyah.
  12. Ṭūsī, Abū Jaʽfar Muhammad ibn Hasan (1969) Īstibṣār, Tehran: Dār al-Kutub al-Islāmīyah.
  13. Ṭūsī, Abū Jaʽfar Muhammad ibn Hasan (n, d) al-Fihrist, Iraq-Najaf: al-Maktabah al-Murtaḍawīyyah.
  14. Ṭūsī, Abū Jaʽfar Muhammad ibn Hasan (1990) al-Ghībah, Qom: Muʼassish Maʽārif Islāmī.
  15. ʽA llāmih Hillī, Hasan ibn Yūsuf ibn Muṭahhar (1990) Khulāṣat al-Aqwāl Fī Maárifat al-Rijāl, Qom: Dār al-dhakhāʼir.
  16. Fiyḍ, ʽA lī Riḍā (1999), Mabādī Fiqh Va Uṣūl, Tehran: Enteshārāt Dāneshgāh Tehran
  17. Kashshī, Muhammad ibn ʽUmar (1969), Rijāl al-Kashsī (Īkhtīyār Maʽrifat al-Rijāl), Mashhad: Enteshārāt Dānishgāh Mashhad.
  18. Kuleynī, Muhammad ibn Yaʽgūb (1986), Usūl al-Kāfī, Tehran: Dār al-Kutub Islāmīyah.
  19. Majlisī Awwal, Muhammad Taqī, Rawḍat al-Muttaqīn, Qom: Muʼassish Kūshānpūr.
  20. Majlisī, Muhammad Bāqir, (1999), al-Wajīzah Fī ʽIlm al-Rijāl, Tehran: Vizārat Farhang Va Irshād Islāmī.
  21. Muhaqiq Hillī, Jaʽfar ibn Hasan (1986), al-Muʽtabar Fī Sharh al-Mukhtaṣar, Qom: MuʼassishSayyid al-Shuhadā.
  22. Mufīd, Muhammad ibn Nuʽmān (1992), al-Irshād Qom: Kungireh Jahānī Sheykh Mufīd.
  23. Mufīd, Muhammad ibn Nuʽmān (1992), Javābāt Ahl al-Mūṣil, Qom: Kungireh Jahānī Sheykh Mufīd.
  24. Mahdavī Rād, Muhammad ʽAlī, (2012) and Amīr ʽAṭā- Allāh Jabbārī, "Muhammad ibn Sanān Az Varāye Dīdgāhhā" Hadīth Pazhūhī Majalleh, (4), vol:8, pages: 38-64
  25. Najāshī, Ahmad ibn ʽAlī (1986), Fihrist al- Najāshī, Qom: Enteshārāt Jāmiʽeh Mudarresīn.
  26. Narāqī, Mīrzā Abu al-Qāsim (2001), Shuʽab al-Maqāl Fī Darajāt al-Rijāl, Qom Kungireh Buzurgdāsht Narāqīayn.
  27. Vahīd Bihbahānī, Muhammad Bāqir ibn Muhammad Akmal (n.d), Taʽliqah ʽAlā Minhaj al-Maqāl, Qom: Muʼassish Tahqiqāt Va Nashr Maʽāref Ahl al-Bayt.
  28. Vahīd Bihbahānī, Muhammad Bāqir ibn Muhammad Akmal (n.d), al-Favāʼid al-Rijālīyyah, Dijital Publishing in Isfahan: KetabKhaneh Dījītāl Qāʼimīyeh and Qom: Kitabkhaneh Dījītāl Madriseh Fiqāhat.